Nine Cortland softball players have been honored as All-America Scholar Athletes for the 2025 season by the National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA). The awards are bestowed upon any player submitted by a member coach who achieved a 3.50 grade point average or higher during the 2024-25 academic year.

Cortland's honorees are:

McKenna Barry, Sr. (Clifton Park/Shenendehowa) - Psychology - 3.57 GPA in 2024-25
Molly Farley, Fr. (Goshen/Chester Academy) - Exercise Science - 3.76 GPA in 2024-25
Riley Firenze, Fr. (Selden/Newfield) - Exercise Science - 3.83 GPA in 2024-25
Julz Koch, Sr. (New City/Clarkstown South) - Speech & Hearing Science - 3.59 GPA in 2024-25
Lainie Ornstein, Sr. (Yorktown Heights/Yorktown) - Physical Education - 3.58 GPA in 2024-25
Sam Pusloskie, Fr. (Clarence) - Early Childhood and Childhood Education - 3.84 GPA in 2024-25
Shannon Scotto, Jr. (Putnam Valley/Lakeland) - Physical Education - 3.54 GPA in 2024-25
Katie Stork, So. (Massapequa) - Inclusive Childhood Education - 3.73 GPA in 2024-25
Sophia Wahl, Fr. (Schuylerville) - Early Childhood and Childhood Education - 3.96 GPA in 2024-25

Previous honors:
Barry - 2023 and 2024
Koch - 2023 and 2024
Ornstein - 2024
Scotto - 2023