A total of 17 Cortland softball players have been honored as All-America Scholar Athletes for the 2026 season by the National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA). The awards are bestowed upon any player submitted by a member coach who achieved a 3.50 grade point average or higher during the 2025-26 academic year.

Cortland's honorees are:

Olivia DiSalvo, Fr. (Scotch Plains, NJ/Scotch Plains-Fanwood) - Psychology - 3.90 GPA in 2025-26
Morgan Ellerbrock, Fr. (Colonie) - Business Economics - 3.75 GPA in 2025-26
Gianna Endieveri, So. (Glens Falls) - Sport Management - 3.58 GPA in 2025-26
Molly Farley, So. (Goshen/Chester Academy) - Exercise Science - 3.58 GPA in 2025-26
Anj Ferrara, Sr. (Niskayuna) - Exercise Science - 3.64 GPA in 2025-26
Riley Firenze, So. (Selden/Newfield) - Exercise Science - 3.89 GPA in 2025-26

Shelby LaMont, Sr. (Amsterdam) - Sport Management - 3.53 GPA in 2025-26
Kaitlyn Macumber, Jr. (Deposit) - Healthcare Management - 3.80 GPA in 2025-26
Kaeli McAnally, Sr. (Islip) - Adolescence Education: Math - 3.80 GPA in 2025-26
Emma Morley, So. (Buchanan/Hendrick Hudson) - Adolescence Education: English - 3.88 GPA in 2025-26
Lillian Morse, Fr. (Burnt Hills/Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake) - Exercise Science - 3.54 GPA in 2025-26
Kayla Pendergast, Jr. (West Hempstead) - Adolescence Education: Biology - 3.82 GPA in 2025-26

Sam Pusloskie, So. (Clarence) - Early Childhood and Childhood Education - 3.84 GPA in 2025-26
Kayla Santo, Jr. (Franklin Square/Valley Stream North) - Psychology - 3.53 GPA in 2025-26
Emily Stavola, Sr. (Somers) - Adolescence Education: Math - 3.50 GPA in 2025-26
Katie Stork, Jr. (Massapequa) - Inclusive Childhood Education - 4.00 GPA in 2025-26
Sophia Wahl, So. (Schuylerville) - Communication Studies - 3.97 GPA in 2025-26

Previous honors:

Farley - 2025
Ferrara - 2024
Firenze - 2025
Pendergast - 2024
Pusloskie - 2025
Stork - 2025
Wahl - 2025